Opinion

Highway accidents: The insane ideas

road accidents in Bangladesh
In order to prevent road accidents in the country, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina on June 25, 2018 gives several directives to concerned authorities which include a restriction on drivers plying their vehicles on the highways to five hours at a stretch. Star file photo

This Eid brought us joy, but it also saw horrors and, as an aftermath, a lot of thoughtless decisions.
Joy we all understand. The horrors came in the form of road deaths. Every day as holidayers returned from home, scores died in road crashes. And this prompted the government to make some insanely funny decisions.
First, it banned movement of slow vehicles like three-wheelers on highways. Later, it allowed them to ply for a small period just to refuel. And then it set a speed limit of 80km per hour on the highways.

Also READ: 80km the max

In my view all these three decisions are ill-conceived, bereft of reality and are bound to fail. Let's examine the facts.

WATCH: CNG autos: A highway threat (video)

It is true the slow vehicles, specially the battery-operated three-wheelers, are a real nuisance on the highways. They irritate drivers, pose as barriers on highway driving and are often the subjects of accidents.

READ more: CNG autos defy ban on highway

A CNG-run auto-rickshaw and a rickshaw plying the Dhaka-Mawa highway on August 1 when a government ban on the operation of all sorts of three-wheelers on highways took effect. Many such three-wheelers were seen running on different highways throughout the day. Photo: Amran Hossain
Having said, that there is little reason to ban them. I have driven through the highways hundreds of times, getting irritated every time I overtook a slow vehicle. Thousands of drivers take their private cars on the highways every day. Yet I have not heard of a private car hitting a slow vehicle. Why? Because we who drive private cars do it safely and with care. That is what a driver should do while sitting behind the steering wheel.
Then why do the buses hit them so often?
That is because the bus drivers think they are sitting in the cockpit of fighter jets and zoom through the highways at breakneck speed, disregarding any safety rules. The bus drivers not only hit the slow vehicles, they are the real menace for any vehicle for that matter. They are the real culprits for all these deaths on the highways. So why don't we ban buses instead of three-wheelers? Will that be a sane idea? Not at all.
Rescuers stand beside a smashed bus that collided head-on with another bus on Dhaka-Sirajganj highway in Kamarkhand upazila of Sirajganj on July 19. At least 14 people were killed in the road accident. Photo: STAR
Then comes the issue of limiting speed to 80km an hour.

Also READ: Total chaos on highways

Our highways are so crammed that I myself find it difficult to speed beyond 65km. Negotiating these roads at 80km is very risky. What our bus drivers do, they speed through crammed roads at 80km or even beyond that speed. The result is obvious: accidents.
In the past the government had wanted to install 'governor seals' in buses to limit speed but the move failed. This time the same initiative is bound to fail as reckless bus drivers will tamper with the seal, if it is at all installed. And the question will remain about who will monitor the speed and whether we have that capability.

READ more: BRTA move for 'speed governor seal' hits a bad patch

Vehicles stranded in long queues on Dhaka-Chittagong highway on the Kanchpur bridge as three-wheeler owners and drivers block the highway, protesting a government ban, causing immense sufferings to hundreds of passengers. Photo: Amran Hossian
But more than that it is the reckless behavior of the bus drivers that causes the accidents. I have often seen them zooming through two vehicles with barely any safety room. They overtake when it seems an insane and impossible act. They violate each and every traffic rule. And why not? There is no enforcement of law to catch them. They stop their vehicle any place at will, blocking the entire highway in front of traffic police. I cannot remember killer bus drivers being punished. And they have their all-powerful unions to protest any action.

READ more: People suffer for 3rd day


So in the absence of law enforcement, the bus drivers become reckless. Stopping three-wheelers or limiting speed will not make any difference to the situation. Accidents will happen and we will take many more decisions with out results.

Comments

Highway accidents: The insane ideas

road accidents in Bangladesh
In order to prevent road accidents in the country, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina on June 25, 2018 gives several directives to concerned authorities which include a restriction on drivers plying their vehicles on the highways to five hours at a stretch. Star file photo

This Eid brought us joy, but it also saw horrors and, as an aftermath, a lot of thoughtless decisions.
Joy we all understand. The horrors came in the form of road deaths. Every day as holidayers returned from home, scores died in road crashes. And this prompted the government to make some insanely funny decisions.
First, it banned movement of slow vehicles like three-wheelers on highways. Later, it allowed them to ply for a small period just to refuel. And then it set a speed limit of 80km per hour on the highways.

Also READ: 80km the max

In my view all these three decisions are ill-conceived, bereft of reality and are bound to fail. Let's examine the facts.

WATCH: CNG autos: A highway threat (video)

It is true the slow vehicles, specially the battery-operated three-wheelers, are a real nuisance on the highways. They irritate drivers, pose as barriers on highway driving and are often the subjects of accidents.

READ more: CNG autos defy ban on highway

A CNG-run auto-rickshaw and a rickshaw plying the Dhaka-Mawa highway on August 1 when a government ban on the operation of all sorts of three-wheelers on highways took effect. Many such three-wheelers were seen running on different highways throughout the day. Photo: Amran Hossain
Having said, that there is little reason to ban them. I have driven through the highways hundreds of times, getting irritated every time I overtook a slow vehicle. Thousands of drivers take their private cars on the highways every day. Yet I have not heard of a private car hitting a slow vehicle. Why? Because we who drive private cars do it safely and with care. That is what a driver should do while sitting behind the steering wheel.
Then why do the buses hit them so often?
That is because the bus drivers think they are sitting in the cockpit of fighter jets and zoom through the highways at breakneck speed, disregarding any safety rules. The bus drivers not only hit the slow vehicles, they are the real menace for any vehicle for that matter. They are the real culprits for all these deaths on the highways. So why don't we ban buses instead of three-wheelers? Will that be a sane idea? Not at all.
Rescuers stand beside a smashed bus that collided head-on with another bus on Dhaka-Sirajganj highway in Kamarkhand upazila of Sirajganj on July 19. At least 14 people were killed in the road accident. Photo: STAR
Then comes the issue of limiting speed to 80km an hour.

Also READ: Total chaos on highways

Our highways are so crammed that I myself find it difficult to speed beyond 65km. Negotiating these roads at 80km is very risky. What our bus drivers do, they speed through crammed roads at 80km or even beyond that speed. The result is obvious: accidents.
In the past the government had wanted to install 'governor seals' in buses to limit speed but the move failed. This time the same initiative is bound to fail as reckless bus drivers will tamper with the seal, if it is at all installed. And the question will remain about who will monitor the speed and whether we have that capability.

READ more: BRTA move for 'speed governor seal' hits a bad patch

Vehicles stranded in long queues on Dhaka-Chittagong highway on the Kanchpur bridge as three-wheeler owners and drivers block the highway, protesting a government ban, causing immense sufferings to hundreds of passengers. Photo: Amran Hossian
But more than that it is the reckless behavior of the bus drivers that causes the accidents. I have often seen them zooming through two vehicles with barely any safety room. They overtake when it seems an insane and impossible act. They violate each and every traffic rule. And why not? There is no enforcement of law to catch them. They stop their vehicle any place at will, blocking the entire highway in front of traffic police. I cannot remember killer bus drivers being punished. And they have their all-powerful unions to protest any action.

READ more: People suffer for 3rd day


So in the absence of law enforcement, the bus drivers become reckless. Stopping three-wheelers or limiting speed will not make any difference to the situation. Accidents will happen and we will take many more decisions with out results.

Comments

চাঁদপুর, মেঘনা নদী, মরদেহ, নৌ-পুলিশ,

মেঘনায় লঞ্চ থেকে ৫ মরদেহ উদ্ধার

চাঁদপুর নৌ পুলিশের বরাত দিয়ে জেলা প্রশাসক বলেন, ‘ওই লঞ্চে পাঁচজন মৃত ও তিনজনকে আহত অবস্থায় পাওয়া গেছে।’

৪৫ মিনিট আগে